old fashioned christmas sugar cookie recipes cut out with icing
| | |

25 Old Fashioned Christmas Sugar Cookie Recipes 

This post contains links to affiliate websites, such as Amazon, and we receive an affiliate commission for any purchases made by you using these links. We appreciate your support!

Last Updated on January 20, 2024 by Allison Lancaster

What could be better than old-fashioned Christmas sugar cookie recipes with icing for the holiday season? Here you will find an assortment of ideas to make that will remind you of Grandma‘s baking. Everything from cut-out snowmen, Christmas trees, and even eggnog flavor with decorating ideas galore! 

Old Fashioned Christmas Sugar Cookies With Icing 

  1. Classic Sugar Cookies 

These old-fashioned cut out cookies are simple to make. You will need room-temperature butter, vanilla extract, eggs, all-purpose flour, baking powder, salt, powdered sugar, whole milk, corn syrup, and food coloring. The sprinkles are optional but who doesn’t love the sprinkles?

assorted christmas sugar cookies on white glass plate
  1. SC With Sour Cream 

Make a big batch of these for guests during the holidays! Ingredients include sugar, butter, eggs, sour cream, vanilla, flour, salt, and baking soda. You will love the flavor that is created when you bake the soft chewy baked desserts.

a close up of assorted snowman and Christmas tree cookies on blue plate
  1. Old Fashioned SC With Sprinkles 

Get your cookie cutters out and make the only Christmas sugar cookie recipe you will ever need. They are so much fun to decorate plus they only take 20 minutes to prep and 9 to cook! Equipment needed includes a baking sheet, silicone baking mat, parchment paper, hand mixer (or a stand mixer), rubber spatula, whisk, mixing bowls, measuring cups and spoons, a rolling pin, and cookie cutters. 

christmas cookies on plate
  1. Crisco Sugar Cookies 

This classic Christmas cookie recipe uses Crisco to help ensure that they hold their shape and don’t spread. Other ingredients include granulated sugar, vanilla extract, eggs, milk, all purpose flour, baking powder, salt, and orange zest. You can use store bought icing to make them extra easy to frost. 

cookies on white plate
  1. Christmas Cookies With Cream Of Tartar 

This is the recipe for the best cut out sugar cookies for the holidays. Learn how to make them with flour, baking powder, salt, soft unsalted butter, granulated sugar, and egg. For the icing all you need is egg whites, powdered sugar, cream of tartar, and gel food coloring. 

Christmas cookies on white plate
  1. Shortbread Sugar Cookies 

This recipe for old fashioned Christmas cookies with icing will melt in your mouth! It takes one hour and 30 minutes to prep and chill the dough properly then 10 minutes to bake. You will need a standing or hand mixer, measuring cups, spoons, a baking sheet, piping bags, chips, Christmas cookie cutters, a rolling pin, and a flat spatula! 

Christmas cookies on table
  1. SC With Maple Glaze 

Glazed Maple Shortbread Cookies are rich, buttery, and fantastic with maple glaze icing. Ingredients for this shortbread Holiday recipe include unsalted butter, powdered sugar, maple extract, flour, and pure maple syrup.

Cookes with maple glaze leaf shape on wire rack
  1. Old Fashioned Vanilla 

This old school cookie recipe is fun and fast to whip up. The author recommends using a stand mixer with the paddle attachment or an electric mixer if you have one, as well as a cookie scoop and a small offset spatula. Ingredients include flour, cornstarch, a vanilla bean split and seeded, and a handful of other common pantry ingredients. 

A close up of old fashioned sugar cookies with vanilla icing
  1. Peppermint Sugar Wreaths

These peppermint sugar wreaths are the perfect old fashioned Christmas cookie recipe just like Grandma taught you. For best results use all purpose flour, cornstarch, salt, room temperature unsalted butter, granulated sugar, eggs, peppermint extract, and white royal icing.

Holiday desserts easy
  1. Soft Baked Sugar Cookies 

This delicious classic Christmas sugar cookie with the best frosting will delight everyone during the holiday season. All you need is flour, baking powder, salt, softened butter, sugar, vanilla extract, and almond extract. For the icing you will need softened butter, powdered sugar, vanilla extract, salt, and milk. 

old fashioned christmas sugar cookie recipes cut out with icing

Cookie Recipes Without Icing 

  1. Cream Cheese Cookie Recipe

This Cream Cheese Sugar Cookie Recipe it’s out of this world and delicious with a soft and thick base. You will need one stick of unsalted butter at room temperature, full fat cream cheese also at room temperature, cake flour, almond extract, and a few other staple ingredients. You can add store bought icing if you please.

old fashioned christmas sugar cookie recipes cut out with icing
  1. Lemon Sugar Cookies

Lemon sugar cookies are the perfect old fashioned Christmas recipe to serve up this December. That’s because they are simple, fast, and assembled using only one bowl. You’ll roll the dough in sugar and bake them for 10 minutes for a buttery and tangy result. 

old fashioned christmas sugar cookie recipes cut out with icing
  1. Almond Christmas Cookies

These tender and chewy cookies are buttery with hints of lovely almond flavor. You will need 1 cup butter softened, 1 cup granulated sugar, 1 egg, 2 1/2 tsp vanilla extract, 1/2 tsp almond extract, 2 1/2 cups all purpose flour, 1/2 tsp baking soda, 1/2 tsp baking powder, and 1/4 tsp salt for the base. Also 1/4 cup granulated sugar for dipping. 

Holiday desserts easy
  1. Crushed Peppermint 

Old-fashioned crushed peppermint cookies are the perfect recipe for Christmas. Plus these ones are dairy free and perfect for cut out shapes. Don’t forget that it’s important to chill the dough for one hour. You will need measuring cups, measuring spoons, a baking sheet, a cooling rack, and a rolling pin.

Holiday desserts easy
  1. Sour Milk Sugar Cookies

Have you ever tried old-fashioned Amish Sugar Cookies made with sour milk? Don’t worry, sour milk doesn’t mean what you might think it means, it’s simply the combination of milk and vinegar! Other ingredients you will need include sugar, softened butter, eggs, flour, baking soda, cream of tartar, salt, and vanilla extract. 

old fashioned christmas sugar cookie recipes cut out with icing
  1. Grandma’s Old Fashioned Cookies

Grandma always knew how to make the best cookie recipes. Like this one that takes 10 minutes to prep with simple ingredients like softened butter, vegetable oil, butter sugar, regular sugar, eggs, vanilla extract, all purpose flour, baking soda, salt, and cream of tartar. 

old fashioned christmas sugar cookie recipes cut out with icing
  1. Instant Pot Cookies

This classic cookie has a cooking twist because you make them in your instant pot. They are easy yet delicious, sweet, and chewy. With basic ingredients, 7 minutes of prep time, and 8 minutes of cook time you will have a delicious end result. Decorate with any type of icing or frosting for some extra sweetness.

old fashioned christmas sugar cookie recipes cut out with icing
  1. Air Fryer Sugar Cookies

Air Fryer Sugar Cookies for Christmas are fudgy, chewy, and oh so soft. They take 10 minutes to prep, 21 minutes to cook, and result in 9 delectable servings. For the ingredients you will need flour, baking soda, cream of tartar, sugar, softened butter, egg yolks, and vanilla extract. 

old fashioned christmas sugar cookie recipes cut out with icing

Easiest Cookies To Bake 

  1. Pillsbury Christmas Trees

Make the holiday easier on yourself by baking these delicious three ingredient old fashioned Pillsbury Christmas tree cookies. They take 15 minutes to prep due to the fact that you are gonna roll them up like Play-Doh snakes and then mold them in the shape of a tree! You will need piping bags, chips, parchment paper, and cookie sheet pans. 

old fashioned christmas sugar cookie recipes cut out with icing
  1. Trees On Pretzel Stick Cookies 

Make a tasty Christmas tree cookie recipe on pretzel sticks so that your guests can hold them while they mingle at a holiday party. Just gather up granulated sugar, sprinkles, salt, baking soda or baking powder, powdered sugar, green food gel, vanilla extract, unsalted butter, flour, pretzel sticks, and egg. Use green icing to emphasize the color of the tree! 

old fashioned christmas sugar cookie recipes cut out with icing
  1. Sugar Cookie Trees With Cream Cheese

Christmas Tree Sugar Cookies with cream cheese frosting are the absolute perfect recipe for a holiday dessert. All you need for the cookies is flour, baking powder, salt, unsalted butter, sugar, eggs, and vanilla extract. To make the delicious cream cheese frosting all you need is cream cheese, butter, powdered sugar, vanilla extract, gel food coloring, and some sprinkles to decorate! 

Holiday desserts easy
  1. Old Fashioned Snowman 

Perfectly thick and round old-fashioned Christmas sugar cookies with snowman decorations made of icing. They only take 3 minutes to prep, 8 minutes to cook, and result in 8 lovely portions. You will need 1 tube Pillsbury Refrigerated Sugar Cookie Dough, Red shell icing, chocolate chips, mini chocolate chips, red and green M&Ms.

old fashioned christmas sugar cookie recipes cut out with icing
  1. Gluten Free Sugar Cookies

If you would like to make some gluten-free vegan traditional sugar cookies for Christmas try this recipe. You will need gluten-free flour, arrowroot starch, baking powder, salt, vegan butter, sugar, almond milk, vanilla, gel food coloring, and sprinkles! 

old fashioned christmas sugar cookie recipes cut out with icing
  1. Snow Globe Cookies 

Try these fantastic snow globe cookies for the holidays. You will need flour, salt, baking powder, sugar, butter, vanilla, almond extract, and eggs. For the icing you will need blue tinted and white. Also, grab up some shredded coconut and sparkly sugar for some extra pretty and popping detail. 

old fashioned christmas sugar cookie recipes cut out with icing
  1. Old Fashioned Eggnog SC 

Everyone will love these frosted eggnog cookies because they are sweet, soft, and melt in your mouth delicious. For the ingredients, you will need butter, powdered sugar, brown sugar, eggs, eggnog, rum extract, vanilla extract, flour, baking soda, baking powder, nutmeg, and salt. 

old fashioned eggnog sugar cookies stacked together

How far in advance can you make decorated sugar cookies?

If you plan on freezing them in a proper seal tight container you can make decorated sugar cookies months in advance. However, if you will be storing them in the refrigerator, plan on eating them within 5 to 7 days. 

If you liked this post you may also like: 38 Christmas Cookies To Make From Scratch, Old Fashioned Cream Wafter Cookies, Christmas Tree Brownies, and Grinch Marshmallow Pops!

Are you excited for the holiday season yet? Now that you have the best collection of old fashioned Christmas sugar cookie recipes you’re ready to celebrate that’s for sure. Whether you’re making cut outs or decorating with icing we have you covered. 

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *